Journal of Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology
Open Access

Thermal Stimulation Neurophysiology of Pressure Phosphenes

Alexander Kholmanskiy^1*, Elena Konyukhova¹ and Andrey Minakhin^{2 *}Correspondence: Alexander Kholmanskiy, Science Center BEMCOM, Russia, Tel: +789151375904, Email:

Author info »

Background

The development of sensing in living organisms began with mechanoreception, and then the organs for the perception of electromagnetic radiation from the Sun and heat appeared. The electromagnetic nature of bioenergy in the process of evolution provided vision to a dominant role in the hierarchy of the nervous system of mammals and humans [1]. This is confirmed by synesthesia of human vision with most of the body’s receptor systems, the total number of which reaches 70 [2,3]. Table 1 shows the most common types of synesthesia of vision and the percentage of people with them from the total number of surveyed synesthetes (1143 people) [3]. The visual nervous system (VNS) plays a major role in the subordination of homeostasis to the circadian rhythm [4,5], driven by special light-sensitive retinal ganglion cells and neurons of the suprachiasmatic nuclei [4,6,7].

Table 1: The percentage of synesthetes with a specific type (1143 synesthetes in total).

The visual system controls the biosynthesis of melatonin in the pineal gland and affects brain metabolism at night, as evidenced, in particular, by the paradoxical phase of REM sleep [4,6,8]. It is also possible that the connection between the nighttime VNS activity and the pineal gland is modulated by chiral cosmic radiation penetrating the Earth [4,8,9]. The close relationship between the neurophysiology of mechanoreception and vision is also evidenced by the evocation of sensations of various glows (phosphenes) when acting on closed eyes with mechanical pressure or electric current [6]

Pressure phosphenes (PP) have been known since the 5th century. BC, in the Middle Ages, hesychasts called phosphenes “Uncreated light”. Electrophosphenes (EPs) [10,11] were discovered simultaneously with electricity. Typical PPs can be triggered by applying pressure to the eyes with your fingers or by listening to loud sounds after adjusting vision to darkness [12]. It has been established in animals and humans [13-15] that action potentials (AP) responsible for PP are generated only in the axons of the retinal ganglion cells that form the optic nerve. Pressure on the eyeball (Human Physiology, 1989), as well as local mechanical deformations of the retinal layers [15,16] lead to disturbances in the structure of Mueller glial cell membranes, which penetrate all layers of the retina, as well as photoreceptor membranes [17-19]. This changes the conductivity of voltage-dependent ion channels of membranes and the distribution of ion concentrations (Ca2+, Na+, K+ and Cl–) in the retinal tissues. Ionic currents in the conducting channels of membranes, in the cytoplasm and in the intercellular fluid correspond to polarization potentials, which, propagating along synaptic circuits in the layers of bipolar, horizontal and amacrine cells, reach the ganglion cells and activate them.

The background bioelectric activity of the retina is normally preserved in the dark and is manifested by the activity of ganglion cells (5-40 pulses/sec) [20] and the potential difference between the retina and the cornea (0.4-1.0 mV) (Malmivuo & Plonsey, 1995). Therefore, the retina is convenient for studying the mechanisms of interconnection between neurons of different layers and zones of the cerebral cortex. In addition, the phenomenon of phosphenes (PP and EP) makes it possible to obtain information on the participation of subcortical structures in the generation of AP in the VNS and on its connections with other sensory systems [21,22].

When alternating current with a frequency of 4 Hz to 40 Hz is transmitted in the light between the Oz-Cz points, the maximum EP rating is observed at frequencies of 16-17 Hz [23]. In the dark, the EP rating is halved and its maximum shifts to ~12 Hz. Thus, the maxima of the EP ratings caused by alternating current in the dark and in the light are due to the resonant interaction of the current with the structures that generate the alpha and beta rhythms of the brain, respectively. The dark activity of the Lateral Geniculate Body (LGB) is responsible for the alpha rhythm [24]. In addition to the retina and LGB, structures of the subcortex that regulate the movements of the eyeball (quadruple, hypothalamus, etc.) can also participate in the generation of the beta rhythm with open eyes [25].

From the analysis of the distributions of currents and fields when the EP is induced by an alternating current of 10 Hz [26] passing between the Fpz-Oz (F-O) and T7-T8 (T-T) electrodes (Figure 1), it follows that the EP rating for the F-O option in ~ 1.7 times higher than for T-T variant. The density of the induction current in the eyes for F-O is ~ 2.6 times higher than for T-T. In this case, the values of the current density and field in the occipital lobe of the brain for the F-O variant are only ~ 1.6 times higher than for the T-T variant. These ratios of ratings and currents between options F-O and T-T indicate that the EP induction by the current between points T7 and T8 is mainly due to the generation of AP in the right and left LGB.

Figure 1: The standard scheme for the electrodes “10-20” on the projection of the brain and the layout of the structures of the visual apparatus in the brain: eye; 1 - optic nerve; LGB - lateral geniculate body, 2 - optic tract; 3 - fibers of the Graziole bundle. Inset LGB and thalamus. The triangles indicate the locations (Kanai et al. 2008) of the anodes (red) and cathodes (blue).

It is known [6] that at high body temperature phosphenes appear more often and orgasm in men is sometimes accompanied by a sensation of a bright flash of white light. Ease of induction of phosphenes when the auditory system is excited [27-30] correlates with a high total proportion of visual synesthesia with four types of sound signals. Cross-activation (Hubbard et al., 2011) of visual and auditory sensing indicates a physical relationship between LGB cells and cells of the medial geniculate body (MGB) [29,30].

The order of the ganglion cells in the retina is reflected in the distribution of zones and cell layers in the LGB structure of the thalamus and is projected by the fibers of the Graziole bundle onto the visual cortex [6]. Obviously, in this case, in the cellular structure of the thalamus and cortex, the subordination of cellular connections of the retina is reproduced in one form or another. This is evidenced by the high prevalence of synesthesia of grapheme-color modalities [31] which may be due to the ease of cross-activation of adjacent LGB zones of the thalamus, as well as areas of the cortex VWFA (the grapheme processing) and V4 (a color processing) [32-36].

The onset of synesthesias is facilitated by the anatomical proximity of sensory systems and the retention of cross-neural connections in the early stages of perceptual brain development [33,37]. These connections can also form as a consequence of the neuroplasticity of the cerebral cortex in response to its local damage or new perceptions [30,31,38]. In a model of the mechanism of grapheme-color synesthesia is proposed, based on the principles of stochastic resonance and synchronization of increased neural noise in parallel modalities. Resonance can be established between oscillatory systems with close frequencies. Such systems can consist of coherent oscillatory LC circuits that model the current channels of axon membranes, including helical molecular structures [21].

It is believed that synesthesias involving the color vision zone (V4) are associated with the network activity of several brain [36] regions located in the sensory and motor regions, as well as in the higher-level zones of the parietal and frontal lobes. Many types of vision-induced synesthesias [3], as well as the strong influence of eye electrophysics on the electrical activity of the frontotemporal lobes of the brain, endow VNS with the function of the main conductor of the neurophysiology of cognitive processes [21]. This is also supported by phosphenes associated with synesthesias of vision with orgasm, hearing, tactile and thermal sensitivity [39- 41]. Thus, studying the physics of pressure phosphenes will help to understand the mechanisms of cross-activation of neurons in different parts of the thalamus or areas of the cerebral cortex [42,43] and the participation of subcortex structures in the neurophysiology of thinking and consciousness [44]. In practical terms, this information will be useful for optimizing the use of metameric therapy tools such as manual massage, acupuncture, exposure to low and high temperatures.

In this work, using EEG and ECG methods, we investigated the dependence of pressure phosphenes and bioelectric activity of the human brain and heart on the effect of light with different wavelengths and elevated temperatures on the eyes and brain.

Materials and Methods

The studies involved 10 physically healthy men aged 32 to 72 years. In most of the experiments, the subjects were the authors of the article A.Kholmanskiy (AKN-N age), and A. Minakhin (AM 60), a manual therapist with normal vision. AK – Doctor of Physical and Chemical Sciences, poet and painter [21] had asymmetric myopia: -3D for the right (OD) eye and -3.75D for the left (OS). He was diagnosed with negative scotoma with visual field impairment OS by 14%, and OD by 7%.

A sauna with a temperature (T) of 60oC-90°C was used for 10- 15 minutes to heat the whole body in a humid and aromatized atmosphere, for which pure water or solutions of various essential oils were sprayed onto hot stones. Non-contact infrared thermometer measurements of body temperature in a sauna give 43°C [45]. With manual massage, the skin temperature rises from ~ 33°C to ~ 38°C [43]. Steam condensation on the skin plays a significant role in the increase in body temperature in a sauna [46]. In the rest room, T of the body was 36.4oC ± 0.2oC. The hands were heated for 3-5 min in heated water (45oC -50°C) or holding a polymer bottle (0.5 L) with heated water. The last version with a bottle (0.2 L) AK72 was used for local heating of both closed eyes for 1–2 min. PP was called after rest-relaxation (R) at room temperature (22-24°C) for 10-15 minutes. The eyes were pressed for 10-30 seconds with the proximal phalanges of the thumbs of both hands or the thumb and forefinger of the right hand. The intensity of PP (IP) was assessed subjectively on a scale from 1 to 10 (1 – barely noticeable barely noticeable enlightenment of the field of view; 10 – bright white light in the entire field of view). The effect of white PPs on the LGB and visual cortex was simulated by irradiating the retina with the light of a wax candle, an alcohol lamp, and a white LED. In this case, a pupil-sized spot of light was focused on the eye with a glass lens with a diameter of 8 cm and a focal length of 20 cm (Table 2).

Table 2: Intraocular pressure (IOP) versus external pressure and temperature. In parentheses, the percentage reduction from the reference value.

Intraocular pressure (IOP) was measured using the Maklakov method and a Topcon CT-20 device with an accuracy of ±1 mmHg, as well as an HNT-7000 HUVITZ device (an accuracy of ± 0.5 mmHg). The measurements showed that, when within the measurement error, the control IOP in OS and OD are equal and the pressure on healthy eyes AM 60 leads to a decrease in IOP by the same amount, while in AK, the percentage of IOP reduction from pressure or eye heating in OS is usually higher than in OD. These changes in IOP are consistent with the asymmetry of myopia and scotoma OS and OD.

The bioelectrical activity of the heart and brain was recorded using an Encephalan-EEGR-19/26 (EG-1) electroencephalograph with a sampling rate of 250 Hz. The device allowed timing the oscillation frequencies (ν) from 0 to 100 Hz and the amplitudes of electric potentials (V) in the range from 0 to 0.5 mV. From the standard 10–20 potential derivation, 4 points were selected on the left (F3, C3, P3, O1) and on the right (F4, C4, P4, O2), the reference electrodes were attached to the earlobes, the ground electrode to the forehead. For timing ν of the heart, electrodes were placed on the wrists at the point of a distinct pulse. The contact area of all electrodes was ~0.7 cm2. With pressure on the eyes during registration of ν, a latex glove was put on the hand for electrical insulation. For the analysis, we used mainly frequency spectra EEG and ECG, which turned out to be more sensitive to the effects of pressure, heat and light on the eyes compared to the V spectra. For comparison, the distribution of changes in the V spectrum over the scalp from pressure on the eyes was also measured using a Compact-Neuro electroencephalograph (EG-2) with the imposition of 16 electrodes in a monopolar lead according to the standard “10-20” scheme. The sampling rate was 500 Hz and the sweep speed was 30 mm/s.

Results

In all 10 subjects, after the sauna, bright white PPs were easily evoked by pressure on both eyes. In most experiments, the glow began to flare up from 3 seconds, after 7-10 seconds it reached a maximum with Ip ~ 7-10 and faded away by 15-20 seconds. At the end of the pressure on the eyes, blue-violet dots could appear against the background of weak white light. AK49 sometimes felt the same phosphenes in the morning after waking up with light pressure on both eyes. Manual massage of the cervical and thoracic spine, performed by AM60 to him and three subjects, led to a relief in the induction of PP with Ip ~ 8. The PP intensity was markedly reduced with alternate pressure on only one eye. In AK70 and AK72, PP induction was facilitated by heating the hands in water with T ~ 45oC-50°C. On the other hand, after heating under the same conditions, the feet to the ankle with a temperature of 50oC-60°C did not develop PP. There was no positive effect from heating the hands and eyes with dry plastic bottles containing water with T ~ 45oC-50°C. When the sauna air was saturated with water vapor or calendula ester vapors, Ip of PP did not change, but mustard mint vapors significantly reduced Ip.

Informative value of EEG and ECG spectra

Frequency (ν) and amplitude (V) spectra of EEG and ECG are given in Appendix. The ranges of frequencies (~4-30 Hz) and amplitudes (~ 5-60 μV) correspond to known brain rhythms (theta, alpha, beta and gamma). Comparison of changes in the spectra ν (Figure 2) and V (Figure 3), obtained using EG-1, shows that the V spectra are less detailed than the ν spectra. On the ECG spectra, changes in ν and V when the eyes are exposed to different factors are opposite, but the product of their values practically does not change (νV ~ const, Figure 4). Similar patterns in the form of νDVD ~ const and νSVS ~ const are observed for changes in EEG spectra in each hemisphere for all areas of the cortex. For the background activity of the brain in a state of relaxation, the value νV ~ 125 Hz ∙ μV, and its changes when the brain is exposed to various factors do not exceed ± 1 Hz∙ μV (Figure 5). In general, the energy of the ECG and EEG signal will be proportional to the product of Vq, where q is the charge of the averaged current dipole that generates V. At a constant value of q, the product νV will be an adequate characteristic of the power of the ECG or EEG signals. The principle of coding information by receptors is based on the variations in the repetition rate of AP [47]. Therefore, the frequency spectra of the ECG and EEG in our case best reflect the bioelectric reactions of the brain to external factors. The informative value of ν spectra of ECG and EEG, obtained by the EG-1 method with pressure on the eyes with a hand without a glove, sharply decreases in all areas of the brain and especially at points F8, F7. This may be due to the shunting of currents in the brain when the electrode on the wrist approaches the ground electrode on the forehead.

Figure 2: Dependence of the frequency ν-spectra of EEG and ECG AK72 on heating of both eyes by objects with a temperature of ~50°C, pressure on the eyes with gloved fingers (P) alternating wax candle lighting of the right (OD) and left (OS) eyes AK72.

Figure 3: V-spectra of the potential amplitudes corresponding to the v-spectra.

Figure 4: Power spectra (νV) of ECG and EEG signals (points C4, C3), corresponding to frequency and amplitude spectra of ECG and EEG AK72.

Figure 5: Dependence of V-spectra of AK70 on the pressure (P) on the eyes with fingers without gloves (a) and a repeat of the experiment after ~2 min (b). Colored lines bend around the low-frequency V oscillations at each contact point.

Asymmetry and kinetics of reactions of the visual system to light and pressure

It is known that the area of the nasal half of the eyes and the number of photorecentors in it are greater than in the temporal half. Since the axons of neurons in the nasal part of the retina pass in the chiasm into the optic tract of the opposite hemisphere, then normally, when the eyes are irradiated with light in all ν EEG spectra, the signals from the contralateral hemisphere are higher than from the lateral hemisphere (Figure 6). In AK70, this effect is enhanced for OD and almost absent in OS. This asymmetry of VNS in AK70 can be explained by the specificity of creative mental work [51] and the difference in the physiology of OS and OD in AK70, which manifests itself in scotoma, myopia, and IOP. The contralateral effect depends on the spectrum of the light source: it is most pronounced for a wax candle, decreases for a spirit lamp flame and is practically absent for an LED (Figure 7). The first two thermal light sources have emission maxima at ~ 1000 nm, and LED in the 400-600 nm regions. Obviously, the sensitivity of the nasal and temporal halves of the retina for LED light is the same, while for IR light it predominates in the nasal half.

Figure 6: Dependence of ν-spectra of EEG and ECG (a) AK70 and (b) AM on irradiation of the eyes with the light of a wax candle and an alcohol lamp.

Figure 7: Dependence of ν-spectra of EEG and ECG AK70 on irradiation with continuous and flashing (10 Hz) LED light.

From the V spectra obtained with the EG-2. it follows that the pressure on both eyes causes an oscillation in the points F7 and F8 closest to the eyes with a period of ~ 2 sec and an initial value of V ~ 1.5 mV. This oscillation decays after two periods, and with repeated pressure on the eyes, its amplitude decreases to ~ 0.3 mV and decays twice as fast. Note that in the V spectra the difference in oscillations in pairs of contralateral points is weakly expressed.

The V values are comparable to the magnitude of the potential on the cornea of the eye and the onset of oscillations at points F7 and F8 is synchronized with the application of pressure. Given this and the orientation of the eye dipole line to points F7 and F8, the short-lived oscillation V can be attributed to electrooculogram signals caused by deformation of the eye muscles and the eyeball dipole. The directions to points Fp1 and Fp2 are orthogonal to the eye dipoles, and therefore the oscillations of V at these points have amplitude of ~ 0.2 mV. On the other hand, the amplitudes V in the pairs of points (T3, T4) and (T5, T6) reach values of 0.3-0.4 mV with a delay of ~ 0.7 s from the beginning of pressure on the eyes. Hence, it follows that the likely stimulus for oscillations at these points is the redistribution of charges in the LGB layers, initiated by currents from retinal deformation. With the same delay, but with a smaller amplitude, V oscillations are excited in pairs of points (C3, C4), and in pairs (P3, P4), (O1, O2), the delay increases to ~ 1 sec and is consistent with the delay PP start flaring up. The decrease in the frequencyamplitude characteristics of EEG signals with repeated pressure on the eyes can be explained by a decrease in the concentration of charges in the layered tissues of the retina and LGB, due to their recombination caused by the first pressure. In , such structures are modeled by capacitor systems as part of neural networks.

Influence of heating of hands and eyes on the frequency spectra of EEG and ECG

The ECG frequency increases ~4 times with heating and pressure on the eyes, while the increase in EEG frequencies is different for all points are observed only during heating. Heating of the eyes did not contribute to the induction of PP by subsequent pressure on the eyes after heating, as well as without heating, did not cause sensation of PP (Ip ~ 0) and led to a change in the background spectra of EEG and ECG frequencies during relaxation (Figure 8). The same result was given by a control experiment of pressure on the eyes, carried out before warming the hands (Figure 9a). However, the pressure on the eyes after heating the hands with plastic bottles with water with T1 ~ 50 °C caused a weak glow over the entire field with an increase to the equator line (Ip ~ 1-2).

Figure 8: Dependence of ν-spectra of EEG AK7 0 on pressure (P) on both eyes (OU) and alternately on the right (OD) and left (OS) eyes with fingers in a latex glove (a) and without it (b).

Figure 9a: Dependence of ν-spectra of EEG AK72 on pressure on both eyes for 20 seconds with gloved fingers before (P) and after warming up the hands (P1, P2, P3); (a) dry objects with T1 ~ 50°C.

The glow flared up for 5-7 seconds and quickly faded away after the pressure on the eyes stopped. ~ 1 min after the pressure on the eyes in all EEG spectra, a 30-second jump in frequencies was observed at all points and especially in the left hemisphere. Perturbation of the ν-spectrum of the ECG is synchronized with it (Figure 9b). These disturbances of the ECG and EEG spectra are highlighted by ovals. After heating both hands in water for 1 min (T2 ~ 48°C), the PP intensity increased to 5-6 when the hands were reheated after 2 min for 2 min in water (T3 ~ 43°C), the pressure on the eyes did not cause a noticeable glow. The intensities of disturbances in the frequency spectra of the ECG and EEG caused by pressure on the eyes after heating the hands in water with T2 and T3 and dry objects with T1 differed markedly.

Figure 9b: Dependence of ν-spectra of EEG AK72 on pressure on both eyes for 20 seconds with gloved fingers before (P) and after warming up the hands (P1, P2, P3); (b) in water with Т2 ~ 48 оС and Т3 ~ 43 оС. R - Relaxation with closed eyes. Ovals mark the frequency deviations caused by pressure.

Influence of heating of hands and eyes on the frequency spectra of EEG and ECG

The frequency of the ECG spectrum increases ~4 times with heating and pressure on the eyes, while synchronous increases in the frequencies of the EEG spectra are observed only during heating and differ for different points. Pressure on the eyes after heating them, as well as without heating, did not cause the sensation of PP (Ip ~ 0), however, it led to a change in the background spectra of EEG and ECG frequencies. The same result was given by a control experiment of pressure on the eyes before warming the hands. The pressure on the eyes after heating the hands with plastic bottles with water with T1 ~ 50°C caused a weak glow over the entire field with an increase to the equator line. The glow flared up for 5-7 seconds and quickly died out after the pressure on the eyes was stopped, and ~1 min after that, a frequency jump was observed in all EEG spectra at all points and especially in the left hemisphere. The disturbance of the ν-spectrum of the ECG was synchronized with it. These disturbances of the ECG and EEG spectra are highlighted by ovals. After heating both hands in water for 1 min (T2 ~ 48°C), the intensity of PP increased to 5-6 when the hands were reheated after 2 min for 2 min in water (T3 ~ 43°C), pressure on the eyes did not cause PP. Note that changes in the ν-spectra of ECG and EEG caused by pressure on the eyes after heating the hands in water with T2 and T3 were more noticeable than after heating with dry objects with T1.

Discussion

The time of AP propagation from the retina along the VNS correlates with the delay time of the PP, and the bioelectric activity of the retina and LGB is consistently manifested in the EEG spectra by potentials at points (F7, F8), (T3, T4), (C3, C4) and (O2, O1). The dynamics of the evoked potentials in each pair of points can be modeled by a rapidly decaying sinusoidal signal generated by the charge recombination current, first between the retinal layers, then the LGB layers [21,43]. In the layers of the retina, these processes are initiated by the mechanical deformation of its tissues, and the bioelectrical activity in the LGB layers is caused by the AP flows emanating from the retina and corresponding to the PP. Since direct eye heating does not stimulate PP generation, this effect should be realized at the level of LGB neurophysiology. The presence of neural connections between LGB and MGB (synesthesia of vision and hear) indicates the possibility of a neurophysiological relationship between LGB and the nuclei of the hypothalamus and thalamus, which are responsible for thermoreception [39,52,53]. The latter include the thalamic nuclei closest to the LGB: the ventral medial nucleus (VM), the ventral medial nucleus (VM), the ventral posterior medial nucleus (VPM), and the pulvinar nuclei (PUL).

In the course of evolution, thermoreceptors developed as modifications of mechanoreceptors, primarily in the skin of the fingers, palms of the hands, and in the cornea of the eyes [39]. The molecular mechanisms of pain and thermoreceptors are not yet fully understood. It is known [54,55] that cold and heat receptors at T ≥ 42oC begin to work as pain receptors. It is believed that at these temperatures, the cold receptor mediator menthol [56,57] will also affect the conductance of other protein ion channels of receptors of the TRPA, TRPV, and TRPM families ¬. Menthol, forming a hydrogen bond with proteins, causes the opening of ionic Са2+ channels and the flow of Са2+ across the membrane of receptor cells leads to their inactivation and loss of the ability to respond to stimuli. The action of menthol, which contains ~ 40% in mustard mint, can explain the decrease in the thermal effect of PP stimulation when mint is added to the sauna at temperatures 60-90°C. The lack of a thermal effect upon direct heating of the eyes and cornea is apparently due to the lack of convergence with the VNS centers of the trigeminal nerve fibers, which innervate the corneal heat and pain receptors.

Due to its incompressibility, water in the vitreous humor and intercellular fluid of the retina evenly distributes the action of the pressure force over all retinal tissues tightly adjacent to the elastic and inextensible sclera of the eye. The absence of PP at the sites of retinal detachment from the choroid feeding it [58] indicates the key role of the physiological fluids of the retina and mechanical resistance from the sclera in the process of PP generation. There are no special moisture receptors in the epidermis of the palms and fingers. Their absence is compensated for by the responses of tactile mechanoreceptors to water pressure and thermoreceptors to the thermal effects of water condensation and evaporation. Hydrophilicity of the skin implies the formation of hydrogen bonds of water with epidermal molecules when hands are immersed in water. As a result of these bonds, the efficiency of resonant heat transfer from water to the blood and epidermal tissues, and therefore to the thermoreceptors, increases. Heat transfer when the hands are heated with a plastic bottle with heated water will be significantly worse, and this explains the absence of the thermal effect of PP stimulation in this case.

In addition to water entering the hydration shells of ions and associated with biomolecules, a certain proportion of free water is also present in the blood plasma and in the intercellular fluid [59,60]. Anomalies of its physical properties in the range from ~ 25°C to ~ 42°C are determined by the dynamics of hydrogen bonds in clusters of various compositions [61]. These features of the thermodynamics of water and its hydrogen bonds with the proteins of the conductive channels of cell membranes can underlie the differentiation of the mechanisms of operation of cold, heat and pain receptors in the epidermis. Apparently, the leveling of these features of water thermodynamics at T> 42oC leads to the observed unification of the mechanism of the pain and thermoreceptors.

Conclusion

The generation of pressure phosphenes is based on the mechanical activation of bioelectric processes in the layers of the retina, which normally occur in it in dark conditions. At the same time, the efficiency of the generation of action potentials in ganglion cells depends on the state of the physiology of the eyes and its adaptation to the professional specificity of the use of vision. Stimulation of the process of generation of pressure phosphenes by preliminary hearing of the hands in water or manual massage of the cervical and thoracic spine indicates the presence of convergence between LGB neurons and neurons of the thalamic nuclei, which control the somatosensory of the body.

Conflict of Interest

The authors have no competing interests.

References

1. Smith CUM. Biology of Sensory Systems. 2020.Chichester: John Wiley. New York.
2. Manivannan M. Suresh PK. On the somatosensation of vision. Ann Neurosci. 2020:2;19-39.  
3. Kholmanskiy A. Zaytseva N.  Chiral Factor of Circadian Rhythm of Human physiology, Int J Res Pharm Biosci.  2018:5(4); 6-10. 
4. Wirz-Justice A,  Skene DJ, Münch M.  The relevance of daylight for humans. Biochem Pharmacol. 2020; 11;4304.
5. Ed. R.F. Schmidt and G. Thews. Springer‐Verlag,1989: Berlin‐Heidelberg‐New York.
6. Medanic M. Gillette MU. Suprachiasmatic circadian pacemaker of the rat shows two windows of sensitivity to neuropeptide Y in vitro. Brain Res.1993; 620 (2): 281-6.
7. Kholmanskiy A. Modeling of brain physics. Mathematical morphology. Electronic Mathematical and Medico-Biological Journal. 2006:5 (4).
8. Grüsser OJ, Hagner M. On the history of deformation phosphenes and the idea of internal light generated in the eye for the purpose of vision. Documenta ophthalmol. 1990:74;57–85.
9. Lövsund P. Öberg P Å. Nilsson SEG. Magneto- and electrophosphenes: a comparative study, Medical & Biological Engin  Comput. 1980;18(6): 758–764.
10. Nair A. Brang D. Inducing synesthesia in non-synesthetes: Short-term visual deprivation facilitates auditory-evoked visual percepts. Conscious Cogn. 2019:7;70-79.
11. Sappington RM. Sidorova T. Ward NJ, Chakravarthy R, Calkins DJ. Activation of transient receptor potential vanilloid-1 (TRPV1) influences how retinal ganglion cell neurons respond to pressure-related stress. Channels. 2015; 9: 102–113.
12. Rountree CM, Meng C, Troy J B, Saggere L. Mechanical stimulation of the retina: therapeutic feasibility and cellular mechanism. IEEE Trans. Neural Syst. Rehabil. Eng.2018; 26: 1075–1083.
13. De Melo Reis RA, Marques Ventura AL, Schitine CS, Fialho de Mello MC,  de Mello FG. Müller glia as an active compartment modulating nervous activity in the vertebrate retina: neurotransmitters and trophic factors. Neurochem. Res. 2008;33:1466–1474.
14. Lindqvist N, Liu Q, Zajadacz J, Franze K, Reichenbach A. Retinal glial (Müller) cells: sensing and responding to tissue stretch. Investig. Opthalmol. Vis. Sci.2010; 51; 1683–1690.
15. Grüsser OJ, Grüsser-Cornehls U,  Kusel R, Przybyszewski AW.  Responses of retinal ganglion cells to eyeball deformation: A neurophysiological basis for “pressure phosphenes”  Vision Res. 1989;29: 181-194.
16. Agte S, Pannicke T, Ulbricht E, Reichenbach A, Bringmann A. Two different mechanosensitive calcium responses in Müller glial cells of the guinea pig retina: differential dependence on purinergic receptor signaling. Glia.2017; 65: 62–74.
17. Hubel DH. Eye, Brain, and Vision, Scientific American Library Series.1995; New York.
18. Baysal V, Yilmaz E. Effects of electromagnetic induction on vibrational resonance in single neurons and neuronal networks, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications.2020; 537; 122733.
19. Kanai R, Chaieb L, Antal A, Walsh V, Paulus W.  Frequency-Dependent Electrical. 2008.
20. Hughes SW, Crunelli V.  Thalamic Mechanisms of EEG Alpha Rhythms and Their Pathological Implications, Neuroscientist. 11(4) 357–372.
21. Jensen O, Spaak E, Zumer JM. Human Brain Oscillations: From Physiological Mechanisms to Analysis and Cognition. Springer.2019; 471-517.
22. Indahlastari A, Kasinadhuni AK, Saar C, Castellano K, Mousa B, Chauhan M, et al. Methods to Compare Predicted and Observed Phosphene Experience in tACS Subjects, Neural lasticity.2018;  8525706, 10.
23. Lessell S, Cohen MM. Phosphenes induced by sound. Neurology. 2009;29(11); 1524–1526.
24. Brang D , Towle VL, Suzuki S, Hillyard SA,  Di Tusa S, Dai Z, et al. Peripheral sounds rapidly activate visual cortex: evidence from electrocorticography, J. Neurophysiol. 2015:114(5); 3023–3028.
25. Roe AW, Garraghty PE, Esguerra M, Sur M. Experimentally induced visual projections to the auditory thalamus in ferrets: Evidence for a W cell pathway, J. Comp. Neurol.1993; 334(2): 263-280. 
26. Hubbard EM, Ramachandran VS.  Neurocognitive mechanisms of synesthesia.2005. 
27. Hubbard EM, Brang D, Ramachandran VS. The cross‐activation theory at 10. J. Neuropsychol. 2011;5(2): 152–177.
28. Lalwani P, Brang D.  Stochastic resonance model of synesthesia. Philos. Trans. R Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci.2019; 374(1787):20190029.
29. Rouw R, Scholte HS. Increased structural connectivity in grapheme–color synesthesia. Nat. Neurosci. 2007;10: 792-797.
30. Maurer D, Ghloum JK, Gibson LC, Watson MR, Chen LM, Akins K, et al. Reduced perceptual narrowing in synesthesia. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.2020;117(18):10089-10096. 
31. Sur M, Garraghty P E, Roe AW. Experimentally-induced visual projections into auditory thalamus and cortex, Science.1989; 242: 1437—1441.
32. Gaglianese A, Branco MP, Groen IIA, Benson NC, Vansteensel MJ, Murray MM, et al. Electrocorticography Evidence of Tactile Responses in Visual Cortices, Brain Topogr. 2020; 33(5): 559–570.
33. Snyder AC, Issar D, Smith MA. What does scalp electroencephalogram coherence tell us about long-range cortical networks? European J Neuroscience. 2018;48(7): 2466-2481.
34. Interconnection of electrical oscillations of the heart and brain. Bull. St.-P. State Univ. Med. 2018; 13(2): 117-135.
35. Vandewalle G , Maquet P, Dijk D. Light as a modulator of cognitive brain function, Trends Cogn Sci.2009; 13(10):429-38. 
36. Hermans LFJ , Vesala T. The sauna – revisited, Europhysics News.2007;  38(6): 32-32.
37. Kholmanskiy AS, Minakhin AA.  Physical factors of asymmetry of biomechanics of the musculoskeletal system, Mathematical morphology. Electronic Mathematical and Medico-Biological Journal. 2011;10(3).
38. Zech M, Bösel S, Tuthorn M, Benesch M, Dubbert M, Cuntz M, et al. Sauna, sweat and science – quantifying the proportion of condensation water versus sweat using a stable water isotope (2H/1Hand 18O/16O) tracer experiment, Isotopes in Environmental and Health Studies, 2015;10:136.
39. Malmivuo J, Plonsey R Bioelectromagnetism - Principles and Applications of Bioelectric and Biomagnetic Fields. Acprof.1995; 576-587.
40. Bogoslovsky AI. General pathology of the visual field. In the book Multivolume Guide to Eye Diseases, V. 1, Moscow., 1962;492-502.
41. Curcio CA, Allen KA. Topography of ganglion cells in human retina. J Comp Neurol.1990; 300: 5-25.
42.  Sjöstrand J, Olsson V, Popovic Z, Conradi N. Quantitative estimations of foveal and extra-foveal retinal circuitry in humans, Vision res. 1999;39(18): 2987-2998.
43. Filingeri D. Neurophysiology of Skin Thermal Sensations, Compr physiol.2016; 6(3): 1279–1294.
44. Filingeri D, Havenith G.  Human skin wetness perception: psychophysical and neurophysiological bases, Temperature.2015; 2(1):86-104.
45. Medvedev AA, Sokolova LV.  Features and Mechanisms of Temperature Sensitivity (Review). J med bio res. 2019;7(1): 92–105.
46. Basbaum AI, Bautista DM, Scherrer G, Julius D. Cellular and Molecular Mechanisms of Pain, Cell. 2009;139(2): 267–284.
47. Fernández-Carvajal A, Fernández-Ballester G, Devesa I, González-Ros J M, Ferrer-Montiel A. (2012)  New Strategies to Develop Novel Pain Therapies: Addressing Thermoreceptors from Different Points of View, Pharmaceuticals.2012; 5: 16-48.
48. Rouw R, Scholte HS, Colizoli OJ. Brain areas involved in synaesthesia: a review. J neuropsychol. 2011;5(2): 214-42. 
49. Kozyreva TV, Tkachenko EYa.  Effect of menthol on human temperature sensitivity. Human physiology. 2008;34(2): 221–225.
50. Xu L, HanY, Chen X.  Molecular mechanisms underlying menthol binding and activation of TRPM8 ion channel. Nat commun.2020; 11: 3790.
51. Modern Ophthalmology. A Guide. 2nd ed. Ed. V.F. Danilichev. SPb. Piter. 2009
52. Bagchi B. Water in Biological and Chemical Processes: From Structure and Dynamics to Function.2013.
53. Matveev VV. Cell theory, intrinsically disordered proteins, and the physics of the origin of life,  Prog biophys mol biol. 2019;149: 114-130.
54. Bardik V. The crucial role of water in the formation of the physiological temperature range for warm-blooded organisms. J Mol Liq. 2020;306: 112818.
55. Dashchinskaya TN, Dashchinskiy VE, Kholmanskiy AS. Sociocultural and psychophysical foundations of artistic creativity, Modern problems of science and education. 2012.
56. Kholmanskiy, A. Hydrogen bonds and dynamics of liquid water and alcohols. J Mol Liq.2021; 11:5237.
57. Konyukhov NI.  Cosmic energies and humanity: haplogroups, psychotypes, society. Moscow. 2018.
58. Page NGR, Bolger JP, Sanders, MD. Auditory evoked phosphenes in optic nerve disease. J Neuron Neurosur Psych. 1982; 45(1): 7–12.
59. Ramachandran VS, Hubbard EM. Synaesthesia – a window into perception, thought and language. J Consc Stud. 2001; 8, 3-34.